The film follows the story of Lilly Leonard (played by Bette Midler) and Dan De Mora (played by Dennis Farina), a divorced couple who have been bitterly estranged for many years. Their daughter, Molly (played by Paula Marshall), is about to get married, and both Lilly and Dan are determined to attend her wedding despite their mutual animosity.
At the wedding, Lilly and Dan’s long-standing resentment towards each other quickly resurfaces, leading to a heated argument that escalates into a physical altercation. However, in a surprising turn of events, their passionate confrontation reignites the spark of their former romance, and they find themselves unable to resist each other’s charms.
As Lilly and Dan embark on a whirlwind romance, they must navigate the complications of their past and present relationships, including Lilly’s marriage to her wealthy second husband Alan (played by David Rasche) and Dan’s engagement to his much younger girlfriend Rowena (played by Gail O’Grady). Despite their best efforts to keep their affair a secret, their tumultuous relationship threatens to derail Molly’s wedding and disrupt their lives once again.
In the climax of the film, Lilly and Dan must confront the consequences of their actions and decide whether their rekindled romance is worth fighting for. As they grapple with their feelings and the impact of their choices on their loved ones, they come to realize that true love is worth taking a chance on, even if it means risking everything they hold dear.
In the end, Lilly and Dan make a bold decision to pursue their happiness together, setting aside their differences and embracing the possibility of a second chance at love. The film concludes with Lilly and Dan dancing joyously at Molly’s wedding, surrounded by their family and friends, as they begin a new chapter in their lives together.
“That Old Feeling” is praised for its witty humor, charming performances, and heartwarming exploration of love and forgiveness. It’s a delightful romantic comedy that reminds audiences that love knows no bounds and that sometimes, the most unexpected relationships can lead to the greatest happiness.