The film tells the story of Frankie Lymon (played by Larenz Tate), a charismatic and talented singer who rose to fame in the 1950s as the lead vocalist of the Teenagers. Frankie’s smooth vocals and energetic stage presence propelled him to stardom, earning him legions of adoring fans.
However, Frankie’s success is overshadowed by personal struggles and legal troubles. He battles addiction and recklessness, which ultimately lead to his untimely death from a heroin overdose at the age of 25.
The narrative of the film is framed by a legal battle over Frankie’s estate following his death. Three women come forward claiming to be Frankie’s widow and seeking control of his royalties: Zola Taylor (played by Halle Berry), Elizabeth Waters (played by Vivica A. Fox), and Emira Eagle (played by Lela Rochon).
Through a series of flashbacks and courtroom scenes, the film explores Frankie’s relationships with each of these women and the impact he had on their lives. It delves into the complexities of love, fame, and betrayal, as well as the exploitation and manipulation that often accompany success in the music industry.
As the legal proceedings unfold, each woman recounts her version of events and offers insight into Frankie’s character and their tumultuous relationships with him. Despite their differences, they share a common bond in their love for Frankie and their desire to preserve his legacy.
In the end, the court rules in favor of Elizabeth Waters, who provides evidence of her marriage to Frankie and claims the rights to his estate. However, the film leaves open-ended questions about the true nature of Frankie’s relationships and the authenticity of the women’s claims.
“Why Do Fools Fall in Love” is praised for its compelling performances, particularly from Larenz Tate as Frankie Lymon and Halle Berry as Zola Taylor. It offers a poignant and thought-provoking exploration of love, loss, and the price of fame, set against the backdrop of the vibrant music scene of the 1950s and 1960s.