The film follows Michael Felgate (played by Hugh Grant), a British auctioneer who becomes engaged to Gina Vitale (played by Jeanne Tripplehorn), a beautiful woman from New York. However, as their relationship deepens, Michael discovers that Gina’s family is deeply involved in organized crime.
Gina’s father, Frank Vitale (played by James Caan), is a powerful mafia boss who runs an art gallery as a front for his illegal activities. When Michael inadvertently witnesses a murder committed by one of Frank’s associates, he is reluctantly drawn into the criminal underworld.
To make matters worse, Michael’s innocence and naivety make him the perfect pawn for Frank’s schemes. Frank enlists Michael’s help in laundering money through his auction house, putting Michael in increasingly dangerous and absurd situations.
As Michael struggles to navigate the treacherous waters of organized crime, he must also contend with the disapproval of Gina’s family, who are wary of his involvement in their illicit affairs. Despite their love for each other, Michael and Gina find themselves caught between their loyalty to each other and their loyalty to their respective families.
In a climactic showdown, Michael’s cover is blown, and he finds himself in mortal danger as Frank’s associates close in on him. With Gina’s help, Michael manages to escape from Frank’s clutches and expose his criminal activities to the authorities.
In the end, Frank is arrested, and Michael and Gina are free to pursue their relationship without the shadow of organized crime hanging over them. The film concludes with Michael and Gina getting married, surrounded by their friends and family, and finally able to start their lives together without fear of interference from the mob.
“Mickey Blue Eyes” is a charming and comedic take on the classic romantic comedy genre, blending elements of romance, humor, and suspense. Through its witty dialogue, eccentric characters, and clever plot twists, the film offers an entertaining and lighthearted exploration of love, loyalty, and the ties that bind us to family, both blood-related and otherwise.